Medicare in Your Chiropractic Office: Is Your Documentation In Order?

Lisa J. Barnett

Lisa J. Barnett

Have you ever thought you could be both a great documenter and repeatedly educate your patients on their innate intelligence . . . if you only had the time? Keep reading on how to both bulletproof your documentation for a potential audit and maintain the energy of our profession’s principles.

Let’s help build your ammunition.

First . . . did you know that the US Health and Human Services advised Medicare to target chiropractors to curb questionable and inappropriate payments, projected at $280,000,000? Seriously! And clinics are, as I write this, being audited. How do I know? Because we’re receiving phone calls and emails asking, “What do I do? I received a letter from Medicare.” As a result, I’m traveling around to help chiropractic offices prepare.

To insure yourself and what you’ve worked hard for, make sure your documentation (that is, every single note in the patient’s file/your EHR software) is citing the following information:

  • History Obtained at Initial Visit:
    • Symptom(s) causing patient to seek care
    • Family history if relevant
    • Past health history (general health, prior illness, injuries, hospitalizations, surgeries, current medications)
    • Mechanism of trauma
    • Quality and character of symptoms/problem
    • Onset, duration, intensity, frequency, location, radiation of symptoms
    • Aggravating or relieving factors
    • Prior interventions, treatments, medications, secondary complaints
  • Initial Visit or New Onset
    • History (as stated above)
    • Description of the present illness:
      • Mechanism of trauma (how did it happen?) For example, getting out of bed, twisting, gardening.
      • Quality and character of symptoms/problem
      • Onset, duration, intensity, frequency, location, radiation of symptoms
      • Aggravating or relieving factors,
      • Prior interventions, treatments, medications, secondary complaints
      • Symptoms causing patient to seek care. Symptom(s) must be related to the level of the subluxation documented.
    • Evaluation of spine/nervous system through physical examination.
      • PART: pain and tenderness, asymmetry/misalignment, range of motion abnormality, tissue, tone changes
    • Diagnosis: Primary diagnosis must be a subluxation, including the level or identified descriptive term of location, i.e., condition of the spinal joint involved, direction of position assumed by the named bone.
    • Treatment plan, to include the following:
      • Recommended level of care (duration and frequency of visits), specific goals, objective measures to evaluate treatment effectiveness, date of the initial treatment.
      • Though not a documentation requirement, this is where you will educate the patient face to face, as to their subluxation and what will happen if they don’t get it corrected, as well as educate them on their innate intelligence.
  • Subsequent Visits:
    • Review of chief complaint, changes since last visit, systems review if relevant
    • Physical Exam
      • Exam – area of spine involved in diagnosis
      • Assessment of change in patient condition since last visit
      • Evaluation of treatment effectiveness.
      • Though not a documentation requirement, this is a perfect time to re-educate the patient on chiropractic principles.
      • Documentation of the presence or absence of a subluxation
      • PART: pain and tenderness, asymmetry/misalignment, range of motion abnormality, tissue, tone changes
    • Documentation of treatment given on day of visit (technique(s) used and areas adjusted)
    • Progress or lack thereof, related to goals and treatment plan (is the patient meeting goals?)

Let me be clear: The above documentation requirements are not PM&A’s. They are Medicare’s.

Other Tips:

  • Your subjective findings in initial visits/new onsets should tell a story about what happened, how it happened, and when it happened.
  • The Visual Analog Scale (VAS) is not sufficient documentation as your sole objective tool. Use additional tools to measure objectives findings.
  • See below for a typical VAS:

VAS-Lisa

  • You should self-audit your documentation on a regular basis.

In closing, get out there, do what you do best to attract and help anyone with a spine, and follow the above documentation requirements to armor yourself in the event of an audit by Medicare and other payers. Need help staying relaxed and focused, and getting paid? Give us a call. That’s why we’re here.

Sincerely in Chiropractic,
Lisa

Lisa is now providing a no charge initial consultation regarding your Medicare documentation. You can contact at (920) 334-4561 or by email at Lisa (at) @ pmaworks.com

More information on Lisa[LINK]

Download a printable copy of this newsletter [June newsletter]

Download a customizable copy of the Checklist: [Medicare Documentation ChecklistDOC]

Print Checklist (PDF)[Medicare Documentation Checklist-PDF]

 

Your Perennial Waiting List Chiropractic Practice: Like Daffodils, Your Patients Keep Coming Back

petty michel and associates on creating a full office

Daffodils from Linda’s back yard in Wisconsin, 2016

Spring is finally with us and the flowers and trees are beginning to bloom up here in the northern Midwest.

What is amazing to me is that I start seeing flowers pop up where I must have planted them, or someone did, a few years past. Pop, pop… a daffodil here and tulip there, some lilies and Astors and I don’t know what! Who planted these?

Growing, developing, and sustaining a chiropractic practice corresponds in many ways to the laws of nature or the laws of a farm. What makes these plants bloom are many things – the warmer weather, some biological clock, water, of course, and sunlight. Maybe some organic fertilizer now and then.

They also have something else. Something that has allowed them to weather the snow and the cold and the storms so that they are here now… waving to us in the still cool of early spring.

A few years ago I wrote an article about roots and patient retention. I know… seems like an odd comparison, but it’s not really. The thing with roots is that they are not seen and not always appreciated. I made the analogy of having a good root system in your practice – which would be the loyalty your patients have with you. I discussed methods to create and improve this relationship in the article, Chiropractic Root System

I just reviewed the article and realized that I omitted a key component in creating great patient loyalty, patient retention, and patient referrals. It is actually pretty obvious and something I see in the offices I visit.

But first, let me include here some survey information from the 2010 Customer Experience Impact Report (CEI) for North America by Rightnow Technologies* that will help make my point.(My underlines and bolds.)

“WORD OF MOUTH IS MIGHTIER THAN THE SWORD
Consumers aren’t only demonstrating their power with their wallets, but they are influencing those around them as well. Whether a consumer has a positive or negative experience, their friends, family, colleagues and networks are sure to hear about it and what they are saying carries weight.

Customer service is the most influential thing a company can do to increase customer advocacy.

55% (up from 53% in 2009) of consumers recommend a company because of its customer service, compared to products at 49% and price at 42%.

But those who have issues are also voicing their opinions and it can have a severe impact on a company’s reputation and ultimately bottom line.

Imagine the result of 66% of a company’s frustrated customers on a mission to discourage others from buying from that company. Consumers aren’t just complaining when something goes wrong, they are determined to have their presence felt by the company at fault:

  • 79% of consumers that had a negative experience with a company told others about it
  • 97% used word of mouth as their preferred method to share their experience

WHAT MAKES A GREAT EXPERIENCE?
Consumer expectations continue to rise, but their requests are reasonable and within reach. Put simply, consumers want easily accessible, accurate information to make well informed buying decisions. And they want to be respected, treated well, and have their issues resolved in a timely fashion.

Of those who decided to stop doing business with an organization,

  • 73% was a reaction to rude staff
  • 51% reacted to unknowledgeable staff
  • 55% were because of issues that weren’t resolved in a timely manner.”

Finally, it all comes down to this:

“WHEN YOU HAVE A BAD EXPERIENCE, YOU DON’T GO BACK.
This has been a mainstay result from the Customer Experience Impact Report (CEI). The fifth annual report cited that 82% of consumers have stopped doing business with a company as a result of a negative experience.”

So, it is not “time” or “money” as the primary reason patients drop out of care. Simply put – their experience was not AWEsome enough!

This is why Google Reviews or any legitimate review has such a strong impact on referrals. It is Word of Mouth marketing.

But how do you create it? Is there some fancy form or new procedure? A Dx code perhaps? Well, there are forms and procedures, but these are 20th on the list. The first 19 have to do with excellent communication and service. Communication that is genuine and caring.

In the article about increasing patient retention and the root system, I do give a few ideas on how to improve your service and, in turn, retention and referrals. But… so apparent to me now, I left something out!

Time and time again, where I see an office struggling to get new patients… I also notice a low morale office.

The low morale may not be obvious. In fact, studies show that the majority of employees (70%) are really not engaged in their work, but simply go through the motions.** This is so common that blasé, disinterested employees or time crunched, rote professionals seem to be the cultural norm.

But I routinely interview staff and work with office managers and hear THEIR side of the story, at least part of it.

If a team member is disgruntled, disaffected, discouraged, or in any way “dis”, the quality of service they provide to the patient will be affected. Let’s put it another way: if your team is anything BUT happy and cheerful and truly looking forward to their day with YOU and the patients, you have a problem.

There are many studies that show the cause and effect of employee morale and customer service. But I have personally observed it many times myself.

The offices with the HIGHEST patient retention and most patient referrals are the ones where the support team and doctor, or doctors, have a great relationship with each other. In fact, aside from the now and then stress points, you could say that they truly like and admire each other and respect each other’s good work.

Adding to this, these offices also have dedicated a continuous effort for training and education. Webinars, seminars, internal trainings, coaching (Hi there!), and books – one of the most overlooked training tool.

Now, what hampers all this is the stress of running a business. Doctors like to “doctor.” Chiropractic, or whatever good care you provide, does not fail. Doctors can always improve, and should, but it is usually the support organization that finally jams up on itself like railroad cars banging into each other, or even jackknifing.

As many of you know, I am working on a practice CEO training program. After a certain point of practice growth, it becomes difficult to continue to grow the business as a doctor. There is just too much to do. This is why you now need to learn and implement some fast flow procedures as a CEO, procedures which are very different from a doctor.

The CEO is a leader. John Maxwell*** lists five levels of leadership. At the first level people will follow you because they have to. At the second level they follow you because they actually like you! You have a relationship with them. At the third level they see that you get real results for the organization. Fourth… you are helping them become leaders! The last level is many orders of magnitude above the others… they follow you because of what you represent. Think of Martin Luther King, Gandhi, etc.

Practical Steps to Take to Improve Morale, Customer Service, Patient Retention and Referrals:

  1. Improve your communication with your team. That’s it. If it is good enough for your patients and for your family and friends, it is also good enough for your team members. As the doctor, of course, you are very busy. You are here for the patients and we are here for you.  But… as the CEO, you are here for us. Please listen to us, help us get better at helping you and the patient. Schedule time to do this each month with your veteran team members. A few minutes in the office, or even a lunch now and then.  It will pay off! And besides, it is only the decent thing to do.
  2. Plan events or projects to improve everyone’s competence. Schedule the team for training and coaching (Hi, again!) …or have them propose learning activities. Help them become leaders. Help them become expert. Lots of study and training and coaching.

As this happens, a lighthearted sense of pride and confidence will grow in your office. Synergy will improve. Staff will be engaged with the patients more and the patients themselves will also become part of the synergy.

Your practice will become well-nourished and strong, like perennial plants and trees that flower each spring.

Your patients will keep coming back.

#   #   #

Learn to look after your staff first — and the rest will follow.Customer service can make or break a business. If you treat your staff well, they will be happy. Happy staff are proud staff, and proud staff deliver excellent customer service, which drives business success.  – Sir Richard Branson (Virgin Companies)

=====================

Chiropractic Root System and Patient Retention

  *Rightnow Technologies. Download the report here. http://media.stellaservice.com/public/pdf/Customer_Experience_Impact_North_America.pdf

**http://www.gallup.com/poll/181289/majority-employees-not-engaged-despite-gains-2014.aspx

*** John Maxwell, The 5 Levels of Leadership

David Michel to Speak at Moraine Park Technical College – 4/8

IMG_0688-1

David Michel will be speaking on Friday, April 8th from 9:30 – 11:30 at Moraine Park Technical College in West Bend.

His topic “Overview of Medicare Billing for the Chiropractic Specialist”  is open to the chiropractic public with limited seating for around 50 people.  If you or your staff are interested in attending please let David know so he can inform Dr. McLean.

David can be reached at dave@pmaworks.com

Extreme Chiropractic Practice DevelopMENT! California Jam®, 2016

Go Cal Jam

I am standing on a beach by the partially ice-covered Lake Michigan, sometimes referred to as part of  the “Third Coast.”   It is a good day!

Once a year I send out a promotion for the wildest and most unique chiropractic seminar I have seen in 30 years.

“Out-of-the-box” is a cliché that doesn’t really do Cal Jam justice.  Like extreme sports, Cal Jam pushes the boundaries of what is customary and conventional.

But isn’t that chiropractic?  Isn’t that you?

Chiropractic is unique (and wild) because it has purpose and soul.

Purpose and Soul, plus plenty of… Rock and Roll.

At Cal Jam!

Hope to see you there!

Date: March 18-20, 2016

Link to site: California Jam: www.CaliforniaJam.com

Your Most Important Set of Chiropractic Office Procedures

An Introduction to the Practice Development Process of Continuous Improvement

A key difference between a successful and profitable chiropractic business and a roller coaster type practice can be traced back to procedures and systems.

Many practice problems occur because procedures are not established, consistently followed, and regularly improved.   This has been the secret to franchising. Starbucks may offer new products and services now and then, but for the most part, they follow their checklists and manuals of successful procedures.  The local New Age coffee shop down on the corner with the unemployed guitar player usually lasts for about a year before the owner’s savings and inspiration dry up, along with the last cup of coffee.

chiropractic practice playbook

Of all the categories of systems in your office, what would you say would be the most important?

☐Patient Accounts (Billing/Collections) Systems
☐Marketing Systems
☐Front Desk Systems
☐Therapy and Clinical Support Systems
☐ Doctor Systems
☐ Business Systems (Payroll, Financial Planning, Taxes,)
☐ Leadership
☐Office, Practice Management Systems

My guess is that you usually keep most billing procedures in place as… obviously, you need to be paid.  And, you will usually keep most front desk procedures in place. These deal with patients and patients are obviously in the office, or not. And you, of course, follow your clinical procedures.

Your marketing procedures come and go, at least they do in most offices. They are just not consistent. This is why I put together the Marketing Manager System in 2000. The biggest error in most offices with their marketing is that it simply isn’t done consistently.

But the most important category of systems is not so obvious. These are the management procedures and systems.  Why are these most important? Because they keep all the other procedures in place and are continually being improved upon.

Why do you think CEO’s are paid so much money? Because they are in charge of the management of a business and are able to increase its bottom line by the millions.  They have procedures that they follow and insist that others do as well. These procedures all add up to systems.

Over the years, Petty Michel and Associates has been very successful at increasing the revenues of practices. One of the reasons is that we implement what we call the Practice Development Process. It is a monthly system of management that gradually works to objectively improve the business, repetitively over and over.  It integrates into your current systems and does not take that much extra time.  But in the end, it saves you a great deal of time, extra work, and lost revenue.

To learn more about the 3Goals Practice Development Process: 3Goals PDP

The 3Goals Practice Development Process for Chiropractic Success

Four steps to continuously develop and improve your practice

The Practice Development Process is a simple, yet powerful practice building system that can help take you and your business to its full potential of a systematized, team driven and profitable business.

Practice Development Process icon

It transforms your practice. Month by month, it helps move your practice to a more profitable service oriented business that runs at near full capacity – with less ups and downs that demand your time and extra work.

It is based upon the idea of constant improvement.   

The principle of constant improvement in management science has been a major factor in the success of large manufacturing corporations around the world. The success of the Japanese automobile manufacturing rests heavily on a process of constant improvement called Kaizen (kai = change, zen = good).    Motorola developed its own program called “Six Sigma”, a process of continuous improvement.

Kaizen

We have adapted these processes to be applied in practice management and call it the 3Goals Practice Development Process (PDP).

The Practice Development Process has four steps:

  1. Access
  2. Plan
  3. Supervise
  4. Document

Integrate This Process As Part Of Your Team Meetings. The first two steps, Assess and Plan, are usually done before or during the first staff meeting of the month. Supervision goes on during the month to ensure that the plan gets completed. At the end of the month, successful procedures are documented in a practice playbook for future training and assessments.

Your Consultant and Coach. This process is best done with your practice and business coach.  Each month, the two of you should work through step 1 and 2. During the month, your coach may also be able to help with the implementation of the plan.

THE 4 STEPS OF THE PRACTICE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS:
1.  Assess and Review.  At the end of the month, look over the statistics and note what areas improved and what areas didn’t. Then check what was actually done, or not done in each area. Use your departmental checklists from your Practice Playbook if you have started this.assess and review

Many business owners still manage without looking at objective indicators. They manage by emotions, mistakes, fear, “bright ideas”and  other flighty factors that ultimately hold a clinic back, or often just burn it out.

Effective clinic managers, like an athletic team coaches, base their actions first on actual outcomes and performance monitors. These are your daily, weekly, and monthly practice statistics. PM&A has developed a specialized form of review which is called Practice Analytics System which we display on our client’s personal Practice Dashboard’s.

This assessment also includes reviewing checklists of the key procedures and whether or not key duties were done.

  2 Plan. Work out the key areas you want to work on in the next month. Pick just one or two areas that will make the biggest difference and make a list of a few action steps that will help improve the area in your office you have targeted. Get the actions assigned with a date on when they should be done.

game plan

 

3 Supervise.  Regularly monitor the implementation of the action steps with yourself, your team, and your consultant. Provide help where needed to get them done.

4  Systematize. You do not want to keep inventing the wheel, so at the end of each month, document any procedure that worked well.

List all successful activities for each department and “lock them in” as standard operating procedures. Keep what works, throw out what doesn’t. Start with just a checklist of key procedures. Later, you can write or videotape a description of each procedure. It is from this that you will do your training and “coaching reviews.” Use your playbook often: refer to it and practice.

playbook

 

Gradually, you should have your own system of practice management and patient management and have it outlined simply in your Practice Playbook. For example, the “Smith Chiropractic System of Patient Management.”

 

IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
Week 1. First Week of the Month: Do Steps 1 & 2 – Assess and Plan
Week 2. Supervise. Coordinate upcoming activities. Study and Train. (Optional: Separate Marketing Meeting)
Week 3. Supervise. Coordinate upcoming activities. Study and Train.
Week 4. Supervise. Coordinate on upcoming activities. Celebrate and party for a great month! Add to Practice Playbook.

 

REPETITION
Do The Practice Development Process Every Month.
The success of this process derives much of its power
from a simple principle from Aristotle.

aristotle

“We are what we repeatedly do.
Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.”

This often referenced quote is from a series of lectures he was to have given at the Greek Lyceum on ethics (300 B.C.).   We could say, then, that continuing to do the Practice Development Assessment, and all of your procedures and systems, is ethical and leads to excellence. The contrary would also be true.

 

GOALS AND CONSTANT IMPROVEMENT
It is important to keep in mind WHY we are doing the PDP each month.

It is assumed we all want to improve, that improvement  is possible, and that we have higher purposes and goals.  Our patients do. That is why they see us and  we help them improve and get closer to their goals at each visit.

By consistently working the 3 Goals  Practice Development Process each month you, the practice, and each team member will also get closer to the higher goals each of you share.

goals sun

Kaizen: Constant Practice Improvement – From Wooden to Deming

What improvements do you need to make in your practice for 2016?

Managing your practice is similar to managing a sports team in many ways. There are goals, rules, plays (procedures,) skill development, strategies, winning and losing. There is also coaching and training.

The teams that win the most constantly work to improve. But the improvements often focus on just the refinement of the basics.

One chiropractor I worked with told me stories about his experiences with John Wooden. Coach Wooden was a very successful basketball coach who coached the UCLA basketball team to 10 national championships over a 12-year period.

Here is what Coach Wooden has said:

“When you improve a little each day, eventually big things occur…. Not tomorrow, not the next day, but eventually a big gain is made. Don’t look for the big, quick improvement. 

Seek the small improvement one day at a time. That’s the only way it happens – and when it happens, it lasts.”

 

In Japan they have something called Kaizen. This means continuous improvement. Part of this was developed by another Midwesterner (Wooden was from Indiana), Edwards Deming (Iowa).

Kaizen

The Deming Cycle is a process of continuous improvement that helped grow the Japanese car industry in the 60’s to what it is today. For a long time, Detroit auto companies weren’t that interested in what Deming had to say – and, of course, we can see how that turned out for them!

Constant improvement takes discipline. Those of you who had to practice a musical instrument or an athletic skill in school remember the daily routine. Improving the little things can get boring and when a colleague calls with excitement about this new seminar or gadget or website, many doctors are off to the chase the “shiny things.”

Innovation needs to happen, certainly. But the real successful businesses and teams continually work to master what they already do.

Mastering the basics is always the key to success. Deliberate practice, study and good coaching. And this takes discipline and… a certain degree of humility to admit you can personally improve.

But since you are not a full time coach and mostly work IN the practice, you have to schedule specific times to work ON the practice. But what do you work on? ICD 11? (Yes… it IS on the horizon!) More E.H.R?

Well, maybe, but these are not the areas that will significantly improve your business over the long run and take it to the next level.

To help you uncover what should be improved, you can use our updated Practice Progress Grid. You can go over it with your team and plot where you were, where you are now… and then where you want to be next year! (Link is below.)

This can help reveal what organizational and engineering steps you need to build a better business machine for 2016.

In most cases, the improvements don’t have to be major. They just have to be continuously refined. But some areas that are holding you back from your goals can be hidden or overlooked.

If you want to dig deeper, we also have our Practice Development Assessment(PDA). It takes more time to complete but gives you a more complete analysis. (The link is below.)

The world is changing faster and faster. You have to constantly improve to keep up, let alone, to stay ahead. And if you don’t… well, your patients will be going to those offices that are.

From all of us at PM&A, we look forward to your continued improvements and to helping you get closer to your goals in the New Year.

Ed Petty

Link to Practice Progress Grid
Link to Practice Development Assessment (No charge for first 15 users, $25 thereafter.)

Presidential Award Given to Dave Michel of Petty Michel & Associates

Dave's CSW Award

Dr. LaGuardia, Dr. Conway  with David Michel of Petty Michel & Associates

MILWAUKEE, WI – November 27, 2015 – Petty, Michel and Associates (PM&A), a national chiropractic practice management company, is pleased to announce that David Michel, a partner with PM&A, was recently awarded the 2015 Presidential Award by the Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin (CSW). The award, presented during the Awards Ceremony at the CSW’s second annual 2015 Health & Wellness Summit, held at the Kalahari Resort in the Wisconsin Dells this past October 9th through the 11th, identifies:

  • Those who have made significant contributions to the mission of CSW
  • Those who have served selflessly expecting little in return
  • The acknowledgement is to give thanks and recognition to the individual for all their hard work and commitment

Mr. Michel serves on the Board of Directors for the Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin (CSW). The CSW is a member driven and member controlled State organization that develops and maintains positive relations with consumers (patients), chiropractors, legislators, lobbyists, insurance companies and medical providers.

Dr. Jay LaGuardia, President of the CSW, when presenting the award to Michel, stated:  “We would not have been able to achieve the success we have thus far without his valuable service.”

David Michel has been involved with the Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin since its inception in 2012.

Petty Michel & Associates (PM&A), a practice development company, was founded in 1988 as an alternative to conventional practice management seminar programs.  For more information, go to: http://www.pmaworks.com

Medicare Changes: National Government Services LCDs: Effective 12/1/2015

*This notice specifically pertains to those offices where the Provider of Medicare is NGS:  CT, IL, ME, MA, MN, NH, NY, RI, VT, and WI.

 

For those of you who have NGS as their Medicare provider (states listed above), we wanted to make sure you were aware of a new policy which has some big changes, mostly positive and where you could get more information about it.

The NGS(National Government Services) recently published the new Chiropractic Medicare Policy which will go into effect on 12/1/2015

For more information on the chiropractic medicare policy visit:

L66315 Chiropractic Services Policy

Sincerely,
Dave

Tent Poster – The Parable of Responsibility

Everybody, Somebody, Anybody, and Nobody were members of a group

There was an important job to do and Everybody was asked to do it.

Everybody was sure that Somebody would do it.

Anybody would have done it, but Nobody did it.

Somebody got angry because it was Everybody’s job.

Everybody thought Anybody would do it, but Nobody realized that Anybody wouldn’t do it.

It ended up that Everybody, blamed Somebody, when Nobody did, what Anybody could have done.

(abridged version of a poem by Charles Osgood)

Shaw

Printable version of the tent poster The Parable of Responsibility

Tent Poster – Mr. Rodgers Responsibility

“We live in a world in which we need to share responsibility, it’s easy to say  “It’s not my child, not my community, not my world, not my problems”.

Then there are those who see the need and respond, I consider those people my heroes.”

~Fred Rodgers

Shaw

Printable version of the Tent Poster  Mr Rodgers Responsibility